Comey ‘broke norms but not biased’ – agency watchdog report

ComeyImage copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Mr Comey has come under fire from both Democrats and Republicans

A highly anticipated US Department of Justice report accuses ex-FBI director James Comey of being “insubordinate” but not biased, US media report.

Inspector General Michael Horowitz found Mr Comey broke “dramatically from FBI and department norms” in handling a probe into Hillary Clinton’s emails.

The 500-page report examines actions by top FBI and justice department officials before the 2016 election.

The inspector general’s report will be released in full later on Thursday.

The report found while Mr Comey’s actions were not the result of political bias, “by departing so clearly and dramatically from FBI and department norms, the decisions negatively impacted the perception of the FBI and the department as fair administrators of justice”, according to Bloomberg News.

Why was there a report?

In announcing the review in January 2017, Mr Horowitz said that there was overwhelming demand from lawmakers, members of the public, and “various organisations” to investigate claims of unprofessional behaviour on the part of the justice department and FBI employees.

US President Donald Trump is among the most vocal critics of the FBI and the Department of Justice, repeatedly accusing several employees of being biased against him.

The report focuses on Mr Comey’s decision in July 2016, then FBI director, to hold a news conference announcing that Mrs Clinton would not be criminally charged for using a private email server for classified information during her time as US secretary of state.

Eleven days before the presidential election, Mr Comey announced that the bureau was investigating new emails related to the Clinton email probe.

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Mr Comey released a book earlier this year detailing his decisions as FBI director

Mrs Clinton and her aides have blamed Mr Comey for her election loss to Mr Trump while Democrats pointed out he that remained silent at the time about an investigation into possible collusion between Russia and the Trump campaign.

Mr Trump’s decision to fire Mr Comey in May 2017 led the Department of Justice to appoint ex-FBI director Robert Mueller to open a special counsel investigation into the Russia investigation.

Mr Trump has repeatedly denied any collusion with the Kremlin, calling Russia investigation a “witch hunt”.

What is in the report?

The report criticises Mr Comey and other senior officials for decisions made in the lead-up to the US election in 2016.

The inspector general found “a troubling lack of any direct, substantive communication” between Mr Comey and former Attorney General Loretta Lynch.

But the report also touched on text messages exchanged between two FBI officials who later worked on Special Counsel Mueller’s investigation.

Republicans have seized on exchanges between Peter Strzok, a senior counter-intelligence agent, and Lisa Page, an FBI lawyer who also temporarily worked on the Mueller investigation and with whom Mr Strzok was having an extramarital affair, to argue that the agency was biased against Mr Trump.

When Ms Page asked if Mr Trump would become president, Mr Strzok responded: “”No. No he won’t. We’ll stop it,” according to a copy of the report, obtained by the Washington Post.

What is the reaction?

On Thursday, the president took to Twitter to deny that there was any collusion and to call the allegations “phony” and “a pile of garbage”.

Mr Trump has also criticised Mr Comey for his handling of the Clinton email investigation.

“After years of Comey, with the phony and dishonest Clinton investigation (and more), running the FBI, its reputation is in Tatters – worst in History! But fear not, we will bring it back to greatness,” Mr Trump tweeted in December.

Republican congressman Trey Gowdy, chairman of the House Oversight Committee, said in a statement: “I am alarmed, angered, and deeply disappointed by the Inspector General’s finding of numerous failures”.

He criticised the FBI and justice department for the report’s findings, saying it “destroys confidence in the impartiality of the institutions I have long served, respected, and believed in”.

He called on the current FBI director and attorney general to urgently “take decisive action to restore Americans’ confidence in our justice system”.

Comey ‘broke norms but not biased’ – agency watchdog report

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *